Tallow soap vs goat milk soap: they are not opposites

What is the difference between tallow soap and goat milk soap?

They name different parts of the formula. Tallow is a fat that becomes the soap itself, and goat milk is a liquid ingredient added to the mix, so they aren’t competing kinds of soap.

One bar can contain both. Our Goat Milk & Tallow Soap is a goat milk soap made with pasture-raised, grass-fed, grass-finished tallow from small family farms, in a 4 oz bar.

Tallow is a fat. Goat milk is a liquid.

Tallow supplies the fatty material that reacts with an alkali to form soap, a reaction called saponification. It tends to give a firm bar with a creamy lather, as tallow soap benefits explains.

Goat milk can replace some or all of the water used to make the soap mixture. It adds milk sugars, fats, and proteins to the formula.

So a goat milk bar may also contain tallow, coconut oil, olive oil, scent, or colorants, and a tallow bar may be made with water, milk, or another liquid.

Compare the finished bar, not the front label

Whether you’re stocking a shelf or filling gift boxes, compare what customers notice and what you pay: the full ingredient list, scent, lather, look, bar size, packaging, landed cost, and whether you can reorder it.

Then ask the supplier the same questions. Here’s how we answer them:

• What size and packaging? Every bar is 4 oz and ships unlabeled.
• Can scents mix toward volume pricing? Yes. All soap bars count toward one tier.
• Is there a minimum? No. Order any quantity.
• Can I try it first? Yes. Soap samples are 2 oz for $3 in any scent.

Weighing plant-oil soaps too? Read tallow soap vs Castile soap. Choosing a supplier? See the best tallow soap sources.